« Web Essentials Early bird extended for a couple of days | Main | Web Essentials CSS workshops looming »
July 05, 2005
Surely, instead of Live8 it should have been called masterb8
The sight of largely superannuated, mostly astonishingly wealthy, self indulgent corporate sock puppets ("rock stars") partying to end poverty, and the attendant media hoo ha (like when was the last time the corporate media gave a sh*t about poverty) has to be without doubt one of the more infuriating loads of BS seen on the planet in many years.
Patronizing, grandiosely hubristic, and frankly part of the problem, not part of its solution, the audience, "stars" and opportunistic politicians pledging some paltry, ineffectual, hypocritical "relief" from poverty and debt can all go home happy now, safe in the knowledge that we are all good guys.
There are genuine, profoundly entrenched, structural inequalities in the world. Going to rock concerts and giving a bit of money won't fix them. In fact, they will make them worse, allowing these conditions to last a little longer. Afterall, in the 20 years since Live Aid how much better off is sub saharan Africa (we'll see in a moment).
AIDS, increasingly devastating some of the least developed parts of the planet will only further impoverish these regions. And the world's answer (via the Vatican and the White House)? Abstinence, misinformation, "morality" driven solutions (like the death of millions, the impoverishment of countless more, tens of millions of orphans isn't immoral but sex is.)
Or how about the real story about third world debt. Much of it handed over to corrupt governments 20 or even 30 years ago in the form of armaments, and now the victims of those repressive regimes the west supported, are forced to pay it back, with interest.
Between 1980 and 2000, Sub-Saharan African countries had paid more than $240 billion as debt service, that is, about four times the amount of their debt in 1980. Yet, despite this financial hemorrhage, SSA still owes almost four times what its owed more than twenty years ago! One of the most striking illustrations of this apparent paradox is the case of the Nigerian debt. In 1978, the country had borrowed $5 billion. By 2000, it had reimbursed $16 billion, but still owed $31 billion, according to President Obasanjo
Choike.org
In the context of this, what value is the paltry few billions that G8 nations are so generously "forgiving"? Or the sales of some tickets to rock concerts?
Imagine if your father borrowed money to buy alcohol all his life, then beat you and your mother when he was drunk. Does it seem fair that when he died, you owed the bank the money he borrowed? That's largely what we are asking of these nations.
We have to keep in mind that the world changes from the bottom up (hey Mr. Bono, that means hobnobbing like the court Jester at the "World Economic Forum" at Davos won't address these problems).
And that's hard. It's not done with a signature and a press conference. Its not done in a day or a week or a year. And its not done without sacrifice.
But there are individuals and small groups whose actions have had a profound effect, both small and large. One of the most astonishing stories barely told is that of the Grameen Bank (because it breaks the stereotype of "impoverished developing world needs our moneyamd help, and pity").
Take a look at this story from the Independent, because I won't remotely do it justice here.
And I'll have another, rather different story about something one person can do to make the lives of many others a lot better. But I'll save it for a little later.
July 5, 2005 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341cbf7d53ef00e5502108348833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Surely, instead of Live8 it should have been called masterb8:
Comments
I heard an interesting story on the Australian Broadcasting Corporation's Law Report this morning about this very thing. Apparently some countries are now taking the lead from Iraq and refusing to take responsibility for debts incurred by now overthrown dictators, insisting that the lenders - by knowingly giving aid to criminals - breached the articles of agreement. And the delicious irony is that was now president of the World Bank Paul Wolfowitz's idea - back when he was Deputy Secretary of State spruiking the war - for Iraq's debts to be written off. You can listen to the program at I heard an interesting story on the Australian Broadcasting Corporation's Law Report this morning about this very thing. Apparently some countries are now taking the lead from Iraq and refusing to take responsibility for debts incurred by now overthrown dictators, insisting that the lenders - by knowingly giving aid to criminals - breached the articles of agreement. And the delicious irony is that was now president of the World Bank Paul Wolfowitz's idea - back when he was Deputy Secretary of State spruiking the war - for Iraq's debts to be written off. You can listen to the program at http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/8.30/lawrpt/default.htm .
Oh, and Live8? vomit..
Posted by: Sara Lander | Jul 5, 2005 11:58:48 AM
Incisive commentary John. Let me ask you the question, if you were ridiculously rich (just imagine it) and it was possible for you to have a social conscience, what would you do to help - besides blogging about global inequity? Set up another charitable foundation or NGO? I think anything raising awareness and at least trying to help can't be too bad... I know the sight of Brad Pitt putting his name to The ONE Campaign makes many a stomach churn but if you were in his shoes, how would you affect the most positive change?
I really like the bottom-up approach of Grameen. Who woulda thought, banks are the answer?
Posted by: hank | Jul 5, 2005 12:02:36 PM
Hank,
very good question.
I think we begin with the observation that it is hard. It's not about saints and saviours, about heros and gestures but about understanding. These are people like us. With families, and societies amd love, and beliefs and hope for the future, and fear for their loved ones. With ambitions and cultures, music, science, philosophy. Some of it we all share, some is unique.
But by understanding in this way, we don't see these problems in the abstract, or something we can pick up today and leave off tomorrow.
We need to change the stories we tell ourselves. About good and bad, about deserving and undeserving, and us and them.
So, if I had unlimited reources, I'd try to facilitate richer, more valuable, more truthful stories being told, and not by me, but by people in Burma and Berkina Faso and the Barrios of Rio. An I'd try to encourage others to listen to and watch and read and cherish and enjoy those stories.
It would be much easier then to get people to care about others enough to make changes in their lives - to buy fairly traded resources, to vote with their dollars based on a companies policies and attitudes, to pressure their elected governments to sign appropriate treaties.
But shift does happen.
j
Posted by: john Allsopp | Jul 5, 2005 12:22:12 PM
I think your comments are somewhat churlish.
At least someone did something.
Better Live8 than thousands of politicians mouthing platitudes and achieving nothing.
There are huge structural problems in Africa as you point out, and you forget the refusal of the South African president to acknowledge the link between HIV and AIDS, and they are unlikely to be solved by doing nothing.
If Geldof and Bono had done nothing, would you have been happier, would anything have been done? If debt is cancelled and it can be managed that any aid doesn't go to furnish Presidential Palaces, then at least Africa can start again.
However if the pressure is not kept up and awareness not maintained then Africa will sink again. So it really needs to be a continual battle, and then focus on Latin America too.
Posted by: Richard Earney | Jul 5, 2005 7:09:43 PM
Richard,
very nice photos.
I'll try to answer ina less mean spirited way :-) when I get a few moments. But for now, take alook at George Monbiot, a fine, intelligent, no nonsense British writer
http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2005/06/14/spin-lies-and-corruption/
And also at the link Sara provides to the legal discussion of the rights or otherwise of the debt we are talking about "forgiving"
This is not about charity, aid, help or forgiveness - its about justice, and taking responsibility. Right now all the talk (incuding yours) is about developing nations taking responsibility (often for the excesses of past dictators whom the citizens of these countries were vitctims of, these dictators often supported by G8 countries - France, US and UK in particular, or otherwise the Soviet Union), but the west too must take responsibility for its actions.
john
Posted by: john Allsopp | Jul 6, 2005 9:34:50 AM
And this probably puts it even better
http://www.monbiot.com/archives/2005/06/21/bards-of-the-powerful-/
j
Posted by: john Allsopp | Jul 6, 2005 9:41:01 AM
There's now a transcript of the program I mentioned earlier. It's here:
http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/8.30/lawrpt/stories/s1406166.htm
My feelings about Live8 were summed up beautifully by Radio National's Phillip Adams yesterday afternoon "an orgasm of self-congratulation without having gone through any of the hard yards to warrant it"
Posted by: Sara Lander | Jul 6, 2005 10:02:47 AM